2022 – Wacey Trujillo, New Mexico
2021 – Reese Jacobs, Texas
2020 – No Finals
2019 – Jessie Everett, Texas
2018 – Logan Wilson, Mississippi
2017 – Kyla Kelly, Alberta, Canada
2016 – Wacey Day, Colorado
2015 – Kamryn Duncha, Louisiana
2014 – Lyndsey Orris, New Mexico
2013 – Brianna Denton, Colorado
2012 – Maddy Dickens, Colorado
2011 – Jacie Sullivan, Arkansas
2010 – Jessica Gray, Florida
2009 – Janey Reeves, Washington
2008 – Kelsey Lutjen, Arizona
2007 – Niki Baumann, Montana
2006 – Keely Jo Weger, Oklahoma
2005 – Kyla Foster, Louisiana
