2021 – Haiden Thompson, Wyoming
2020 – Madalyn Richards, Texas
2019 – Taitum Thomas, OK
2018 – Erryn Hodson, Utah
2017 – Sonora Schueneman, Texas
2016 – Kaytlyn Miller, Utah
2015 – Mia Manzanares, Louisiana
2014 – Mia Manzanares, Louisiana
2013 – Teisha Coffield, Colorado
2012 – Kelsey Lutjen, Arizona
2011 – Hayden Segelke, Colorado
2010 – Hayden Segelke, Colorado
2009 – Tyesha Oppenheimer, Utah
2008 – Bobbi Grann, North Dakota
2007 – Brooke Boulware, Kansas
2006 – Kate Sharon, Montana
2005 – Kirby Eppert, Nebraska
2004 – Lizzie Murphy, North Dakota
2003 – Kirby Eppert, Nebraska
2002 – Deanna Jo Smith, Nebraska (with team Iowa)
2001 – Deanna Jo Smith, Nebraska (with team Iowa)
2000 – Stacey Watland, Washington
1999 – Jennifer Lytle, Utah
1998 – Amanda Kay, Utah
1997 – Lee Mcknight, Utah
1996 – Lee Mcknight, Utah
1995 – Amanda Kay, Texas
1994 – Chasity Rickman, Texas
1993 – Julee James, Idaho
1992 – Tachana McCurley, Wyoming
1991 – Caryn Standifer, Oklahoma
1990 – Shawnda Autrey, New Mexico
1989 – Betty Joles, Arizona
1988 – Kristie L. Price, South Dakota
1987 – Shannon Griffin, New Mexico
1986 – Kelly Harsh, Arizona
1985 – Karen Cochran, Texas
1984 – Shannan Lord, Arizona
1983 – Kristin Casey, Washington
1982 – Tracy Parsons, Arizona
1981 – Tracy Parsons, Arizona
1980 – Tami Noble, Oklahoma
1979 – Kari Manning, Nebraska
1978 – Lori Primrose, New Mexico
1977 – Lori Primrose, New Mexico
1976 – Barrie Beach, Arizona
1975 – Barrie Beach, Arizona
1974 – Barrie Beach, Arizona
1973 – Kit Bryan, Arizona
1972 – Karen Collingsworth, Colorado